I have long tried to follow the advice of the program and pray for people who give me trouble. I’m also inclined to pray in an emergency, for specific people or outcomes, “if it’s your will,” as I’ve been taught.
Now I don’t know if I’m praying to an external deity or not. In my mind, it doesn’t matter. I cannot picture a god who keeps score or changes outcomes based on the prayers of people. It seems to be a very common or universal human trait to think we can influence the cosmos with the power of our mind, and so maybe we actually can. But I don’t live like that is possible. I have two big problems with thinking that can be so. One, it is incredibly unfair if god changes outcomes by keeping score, when obviously pure and innocent people have no one praying for them, and so cannot benefit from the prayers of others when such prayers could ease their pain. Second, if god does pay attention to human suffering and change it for the better based on a prayer, then there are always far far more deserving people than me and my piddly situations for god to change, yet god does not.
Where prayer works for me is in changing MY mind, not god’s mind or the progression of events.
So in praying for people who I care about and love, I would pray that they have all the need and most of what they want. AA teaches me to ask the same for those who cause me trouble. Yet, I don’t think this type of prayer does anything except maybe work toward convincing me that people I don’t like are the same as people I do like (in god’s eyes), and both groups should be treated equally by god. It rains on the just and the unjust. They also suffer droughts and floods.
Going with that, at times I have tried to ask god to give both groups lots of good stuff. This rings kind of hollow for me though, maybe because of my basic disbelief that it changes anything except my mind. And it is my mind that needs to be changed regarding the people I don’t like.
There came a time when I made an actual list and I still have an actual list of people to pray for.
The people I’m close to, who are in my family or immediate environment and who I care about and want good things for are on it.
The people who give me trouble and who are in my immediate environment are on it.
People who have died recently and their families are on it.
People who are in my meetings and who are struggling are on it. After a while, if they don’t come around for some time, I’ll drop them off of the list and hope to add them back in when they hopefully return. It’s just that after a time, I feel kind of blank just hoping this person I haven’t seen or heard about is doing well. People who I’ve had a hard time with, but who don’t come up in life or in my mind very often, I usually also drop off.
It’s one of these who is coming back into my life, who I need to add back on to the list after not thinking about him much for years.
Adding this person back, it’s more obvious to me than before that it is my mind I am trying to change when I pray for and about anyone. I have to consider, why did I have trouble with this person in the first place? Was it him, or me, the circumstances, or what?
And I wish I could say that I’m feeling the ability to give it a fresh start, but honestly, I’m not. At least I think I know the ideal version of what I’m shooting at, which is perfect love. And I know that I need to ask god to change my mind, not to change the other person. And I know that if god doesn’t directly act on my mind due to my requests, the act of my asking and envisioning the ideal works to do it, even better.